Five Italian divers are dead after a scuba excursion into a deep underwater cave in the Maldives went catastrophically wrong Thursday, with search teams still working Friday to recover four bodies believed to remain inside a passage so dangerous that local officials say even experienced divers with the best equipment do not attempt it.
The group had been exploring a cave system in the Vaavu Atoll coral reef, diving to depths of around 50 meters, when they failed to surface by midday. One body was recovered from approximately 60 meters below the surface. The remaining four have not been found, and Maldivian presidential spokesperson Mohamed Hussain Shareef confirmed that a first round of searches failed to locate them inside the cave, which he described as presenting extreme risk to recovery teams themselves. “The cave is so deep that divers, even with the best equipment, do not try to approach,” Shareef said.
Read also: 3 Ministers Suspended By Maldives For Insulting Indian PM
The University of Genoa identified the victims as professor of ecology Monica Montefalcone, her daughter Giorgia Sommacal — a student at the university — research fellow Muriel Oddenino, marine biology graduate Federico Gualtieri and boat operations manager and diving instructor Gianluca Benedetti. The group was on a morning dive near Alimathaa when conditions already flagged under a yellow weather alert deteriorated further, though the precise circumstances of what happened inside the cave remain under investigation by Italian and Maldivian authorities.
Montefalcone’s husband, Carlo Sommacal, rejected any suggestion of recklessness on his wife’s part. He told Italian television channel Rete 4 that she was a disciplined diver who assessed risk carefully before every descent. “Something must have happened,” he said, describing her as someone who had told him on more than one occasion: “This one I can do, you can’t.” The comment captured both her experience and the selective confidence of someone who knew her own limits precisely — making the accident, in his view, something outside the range of what her preparation could have anticipated or prevented.
Greenpeace Italia mourned Montefalcone as a passionate advocate for marine protection whose expertise and commitment had been a resource for the environmental community. The organization said it would miss “her professionalism and her advice immensely” and “that special light she had in her eyes when she spoke about the wonders of the sea and the importance of protecting them.” The University of Genoa issued a statement expressing sympathy to the families, colleagues and students who had shared the victims’ professional and personal journeys.
The search operation, which involves boats, aircraft and dive teams, has been described by Maldivian officials as high-risk given the depth and configuration of the cave system. A second dive was conducted Friday, with rough weather threatening further delays. Maldivian authorities indicated they may seek international assistance if recovery efforts cannot be completed with current resources. Italy’s foreign ministry said its ambassador and a specialist were already on the ground assisting the Maldivian coast guard.
The accident is believed to be the worst single diving incident ever recorded in the Maldives, a nation of coral islands in the Indian Ocean that draws tens of thousands of divers annually for its reef systems and marine biodiversity — the same marine world that Montefalcone spent her career studying and fighting to protect.